Introduction: the Spanish investigation and the rights hidden behind the border
A familiar emergency call in migration practice often arrives at the worst possible time: a Saturday morning, from a colleague in Oujda or Nador, with only a few hours to identify a detained migrant, obtain the removal decision and find the competent administrative judge. The law says that a remedy exists. The bus may already be moving.
That tension between legal protection and physical removal lies at the heart of the debate over violence at the Ceuta and Melilla borders involving migrants. The events at Ceuta, known in Morocco as Sebta, in May 2021, subsequent allegations involving Spanish security forces, and the deadly events near Melilla on 24 June 2022 have forced courts, prosecutors, journalists and human-rights institutions to examine what happens in the geographical and legal space between Morocco and Spain.
These episodes must not be confused. The May 2021 crossings into Ceuta occurred in a specific diplomatic and operational context. The June 2022 attempt to cross the Melilla perimeter, near Nador, resulted in at least 23 officially reported deaths, while civil-society organisations published higher estimates. Each event raises different questions about force, access to asylum, identification of victims, preservation of evidence and responsibility on either side of the border.
The central legal question is deceptively simple: what can a migrant, including an undocumented migrant, actually do under Moroccan law? The answer is not “nothing”. A person without a residence permit may file a criminal complaint, obtain a medical certificate, challenge an administrative measure, contact the National Human Rights Council and, where the legal conditions are met, invoke the international prohibition of refoulement.
Yet a legal remedy that cannot be exercised in time is barely a remedy at all. This article therefore examines not only the texts, but also the deadlines, evidence and practical obstacles encountered before Morocco’s administrative courts, courts of first instance, courts of appeal and Court of Cassation.
The legal framework: Moroccan law and international obligations
Law No. 02-03: the principal immigration statute
Morocco’s principal immigration legislation is Law No. 02-03 on the entry and stay of foreign nationals in the Kingdom of Morocco, irregular emigration and immigration, promulgated by Dahir No. 1-03-196 of 11 November 2003. It regulates entry, residence documents, removal to the border, expulsion and certain immigration-related offences.
The terminology matters. A removal to the border, often translated from the French expression reconduite à la frontière, is an administrative measure generally connected to unlawful entry or stay. An expulsion is a more serious public-order measure, normally justified by a grave threat to public order. A refusal of entry at an authorised crossing point is legally different again. In public debate, all three are frequently called “deportation”, which can obscure the applicable procedure and deadline.
Articles 21 and following of Law No. 02-03 govern removal measures and related safeguards. Article 23, rather than Article 24, contains the special urgent challenge against a removal-to-the-border decision. It allows the foreign national to seek annulment before the president of the competent administrative court within 48 hours of notification. This is an exceptionally short period.
Practical consequence: a migrant who waits 30 days may already have lost the special 48-hour remedy provided by Article 23 of Law No. 02-03. The exact nature of the measure and the wording of the document must therefore be checked immediately.
Article 24 provides procedural guarantees for the hearing, including assistance by counsel and, where necessary, an interpreter. Subsequent provisions address execution, appeal and the consequences of annulment. Articles 25 and following govern expulsion, while Article 29 contains important protections concerning removal destinations and vulnerable persons. In particular, removal cannot lawfully be carried out toward a country where the person demonstrates that their life or freedom would be threatened or that they would face treatment contrary to protected fundamental rights.
Law No. 02-03 is not an asylum code. That is one of its central limitations. It combines immigration control, residence law and criminal provisions, but does not establish the detailed, independent asylum procedure that lawyers have expected since the launch of Morocco’s National Immigration and Asylum Strategy.
The 2011 Constitution: which provisions really apply?
The Constitution of 2011 supplies several legal anchors, but they must be cited accurately. Article 24 protects freedom of movement, residence and departure from the national territory under conditions laid down by law. Article 30 states that foreign nationals enjoy the fundamental freedoms granted to Moroccan citizens, in accordance with the law, and provides that the conditions for granting asylum are to be defined by legislation.
Article 29 does not constitutionalise asylum; it concerns freedoms of assembly, peaceful demonstration and association. This distinction may appear technical, but incorrect constitutional citations can weaken an urgent application.
For access to justice, the decisive provision is Article 118:
“Access to justice is guaranteed to every person for the defence of his or her rights and interests protected by law.”
The phrase every person is crucial. It does not make lawful residence a precondition for filing a complaint or bringing an action. Article 120 also guarantees a fair trial and a judgment within a reasonable time, while Article 121 provides for free access to justice for persons without sufficient resources, subject to the conditions fixed by law.
International conventions ratified by Morocco
Morocco acceded to the 1951 Refugee Convention in 1956 and to the 1967 Protocol in 1971. Article 33(1) of the Convention contains the cornerstone of refugee protection:
“No Contracting State shall expel or return (‘refouler’) a refugee in any manner whatsoever to the frontiers of territories where his life or freedom would be threatened.”
The protection is not limited to people already holding a refugee card. If recognition were required before protection began, a person could be returned while the asylum claim was still being examined. A credible fear of persecution must therefore be assessed before removal.
Morocco also ratified the Convention against Torture in 1993. Article 3 prohibits sending a person to a state where there are substantial grounds for believing that they would be in danger of torture. This protection is broader in one respect than refugee law: it does not depend on persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion.
The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, ratified by Morocco in 1979, protects life, bodily integrity, liberty and procedural fairness. Excessive force at a border may engage Articles 6 and 7 of the Covenant even where the victim entered unlawfully.
Ratification, however, is not a magic switch. The preamble to the Constitution affirms the primacy of duly ratified international conventions over domestic legislation, within the framework of the Constitution, the laws of the Kingdom and respect for national identity, and calls for legislative harmonisation. Moroccan courts can use treaties to interpret domestic law, but judicial practice is not uniform. In urgent cases, counsel should invoke both the treaty and the relevant provision of Law No. 02-03 rather than relying on an abstract international argument alone.
Pushbacks and border violence: law versus practice
Refoulement, refusal of entry and collective pushbacks
Refoulement is not merely another word for expulsion. In refugee law, it means transferring a person, directly or indirectly, to a place where they face persecution, torture or another prohibited danger. It can occur at an official checkpoint, after entry into Moroccan territory or through a chain of transfers involving several states.
A “pushback” usually describes a summary return without an individual assessment, effective access to asylum, an interpreter or a remedy. If a group is returned solely because its members crossed irregularly, without examining individual protection needs, the operation may amount to illegal refoulement of migrants from Morocco or engage Spanish responsibility, depending on which authorities exercised jurisdiction and control.
The fact that a person climbed a fence, entered outside an authorised checkpoint or lacks documents does not extinguish the prohibition of torture or the right to life. Irregular entry may generate immigration consequences. It does not authorise beatings, degrading treatment or an automatic return to danger.
Ceuta, Melilla and the problem of jurisdiction
The border areas around Ceuta and Melilla create difficult evidentiary questions. Fences, patrol zones, gates and operational cooperation may make it unclear where a person was injured and which unit had effective control at the relevant moment. Responsibility does not depend only on a line on a map. Courts also examine the conduct of officers, custody and the authority exercised over the individual.
In N.D. and N.T. v. Spain, applications Nos. 8675/15 and 8697/15, the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights delivered judgment on 13 February 2020 concerning immediate returns from the Melilla fence. The Court found no violation in the particular circumstances, placing significant weight on the applicants’ conduct and what it considered to be available lawful entry procedures.
The judgment is often presented too broadly. It did not create a general licence for violence or summary return. It did not suspend Articles 2 and 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Nor does it prevent a victim from alleging that lawful entry channels were inaccessible in reality, that an asylum request was ignored or that force was excessive.
For proceedings against Spain, the European Convention system may ultimately be relevant after effective domestic remedies have been exhausted. For conduct attributable to Moroccan officials, the first steps normally lie with the Moroccan prosecutor, administrative courts, the CNDH and the United Nations treaty mechanisms accepted by Morocco.
What the CNDH documented
The 2013 CNDH report on foreigners and human rights in Morocco was a turning point. It acknowledged the shortcomings of a security-centred migration policy and called for a radically new asylum and immigration approach. The report contributed to the National Immigration and Asylum Strategy and the exceptional regularisation campaigns.
Later CNDH work, including observations connected to migration and the northern border, continued to call for respect for human dignity, investigation of deaths and injuries, and procedures consistent with Morocco’s international obligations. The CNDH is not a criminal court and cannot sentence an officer. Its intervention nevertheless creates an official record, facilitates monitoring and may preserve issues that would otherwise disappear from the file.
Reports by international and Moroccan organisations have also described arrests, displacement away from northern border areas, confiscation of belongings and alleged violence by law-enforcement forces at Morocco’s northern and eastern borders. Allegations are not convictions; each case requires proof. But repeated allegations impose a duty to investigate that is prompt, independent and capable of identifying those responsible.
The Nador–Melilla tragedy of June 2022
The events of 24 June 2022 near Barrio Chino became the clearest recent illustration of the legal vacuum. At least 23 people died according to the official Moroccan toll, many more were injured, and migrants were prosecuted in Morocco. Questions remain about the use of force, access for emergency services, identification of the deceased, autopsies and whether potential asylum seekers had a realistic avenue to request protection.
The legal status of a victim does not alter the duty to investigate a suspicious death or serious injury. Families are entitled to seek identification and information. Survivors may file complaints and constitute themselves as civil parties. Evidence may include videos, geolocation data, telephone records, hospital documents, witness statements and the chain of custody for personal belongings.
Here is the practical advice that matters: photograph injuries within 24 hours and obtain a dated medical certificate even if no immediate complaint is planned. Take wide photographs and close-ups, preserve the original files and send copies to a trusted person. Two years later, that certificate may be more valuable than a detailed but undocumented oral account.
Asylum in Morocco: procedure, delays and legal uncertainty
UNHCR and the Bureau for Refugees and Stateless Persons
Morocco still lacks a comprehensive national asylum statute setting out the procedure, appeal rights, reception conditions and status of asylum seekers. The institutional architecture rests on the 1951 Convention, a 1957 decree establishing the Bureau des réfugiés et apatrides, or BRA, within the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, cooperation with UNHCR, and administrative practice.
In practical terms, a person seeking asylum generally begins by contacting UNHCR Morocco for registration. UNHCR records identity and contact information, conducts protection interviews and assesses the claim under its mandate and working arrangements. Recognition and documentation by Moroccan authorities may subsequently involve the BRA.
The ordinary process includes registration, an initial interview, a substantive refugee-status determination interview, a decision and an internal review or appeal in the event of rejection. Applicants should disclose persecution risks as early and consistently as possible, while explaining trauma, interpretation problems or missing documents. Contradictions are not automatically proof of dishonesty, especially after violence or a long journey, but they must be addressed.
How long does it take and what does it cost?
The procedure is officially free. No UNHCR employee or intermediary is entitled to charge for registration, an interview or a refugee card. Anyone demanding payment in exchange for a positive decision should be reported.
There is no reliable statutory deadline comparable to a court deadline because Morocco has not enacted a complete asylum procedure. Depending on caseload, vulnerability and the complexity of the claim, registration and initial processing can take weeks or months, while a final decision may take considerably longer. Figures such as “two to six months” for registration and “six to eighteen months” for a decision are practical estimates, not guaranteed legal periods.
The indirect costs can be heavy: travel to Rabat, telephone credit, translation, childcare and lost daily income. Applicants living in Nador, Oujda, Tangier or southern Morocco may struggle to attend an appointment. GADEM, Caritas and partner organisations may provide orientation, but assistance depends on their resources and current programmes.
What does the UNHCR “yellow card” protect?
The UNHCR document, often called the carton jaune, proves that the holder is registered as an asylum seeker or person of concern. It should be copied, photographed and kept accessible.
It is not the same as a Moroccan residence permit. Its legal effects remain less certain than they would be under a national asylum law. In practice, however, it is highly significant: it alerts police and administrative authorities that a protection claim is pending and can help prevent a removal before the risk has been assessed.
If the police retain the original, the holder should request a receipt or record the officer, unit, place, date and time where possible. A lawyer or association can then contact UNHCR and the competent prosecutor. The absence of the physical card does not erase a registered protection file.
Refugee or economic migrant?
Article 1A(2) of the 1951 Convention defines a refugee by reference to a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion. A person moving principally to find work is not, for that reason alone, a refugee.
Real lives do not always fit neat categories. Someone may leave because of poverty but later face torture, trafficking, political persecution or targeted violence. Another person may have both economic and protection motives. The correct approach is an individual assessment, not a label based on nationality or travel route.
Legal remedies against removal and violence
Challenging removal before the administrative court
When a written removal-to-the-border decision is notified under Law No. 02-03, Article 23 requires action within 48 hours. The application is brought before the president of the competent administrative court. The applicant may request an interpreter and legal assistance and should raise every serious ground immediately: lack of reasons, mistaken identity, pending asylum claim, family ties, medical vulnerability, statutory protection or risk of persecution and torture.
For other administrative decisions, the ordinary annulment action is governed by Law No. 41-90 establishing administrative courts. Article 20 gives those courts jurisdiction over actions seeking annulment of administrative decisions for abuse of power. The ordinary time limit is generally 60 days under Article 23 of Law No. 41-90, subject to the special rule applicable to the disputed measure.
Article 24 of Law No. 41-90 permits a request to suspend execution when an annulment action has been filed and the circumstances justify suspension. There is no universal statutory promise that the judge will decide within 48 or 72 hours. Some urgent applications move quickly; others do not. Counsel should file the merits action and suspension request together, attach evidence of imminent execution, and obtain a stamped filing receipt.
Jurisdiction must also be checked. Depending on the authority issuing the decision and the place of execution, the case may belong before the Administrative Court of Rabat, Oujda or another competent court. Since the creation of administrative courts of appeal, appellate jurisdiction no longer follows the older structure described in outdated guides.
Filing a criminal complaint for border violence
A migrant assaulted on Moroccan territory may complain to the police, gendarmerie or directly to the Procureur du Roi at the competent court of first instance. Articles 400 to 403 of the Moroccan Criminal Code punish intentional assault and battery, with the classification depending on incapacity for work, premeditation, use of a weapon and the seriousness of the injuries.
Where torture is alleged against a public official, Article 231-1 of the Criminal Code defines torture, while Articles 231-2 and following establish penalties and aggravating circumstances. Not every unlawful blow legally qualifies as torture; the purpose, intensity and official involvement must be examined. Conduct that falls short of torture may still constitute assault, abuse of authority or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.
A complaint should contain names where known, physical descriptions, uniforms, vehicle numbers, unit markings, exact locations, dates, witnesses and medical evidence. “The police hit me” may be truthful but difficult to investigate. “At 06:40 near Gate X, an officer wearing this insignia struck my left arm; witness Y filmed it” gives the prosecutor a usable lead.
If the complaint is closed or no effective investigation follows, counsel may examine a complaint with civil-party status before the investigating judge, subject to the rules of the Code of Criminal Procedure and a possible security deposit. That route is more technical and should not be attempted without advice from a Moroccan criminal lawyer.
CNDH, the Ombudsman and international mechanisms
A complaint can also be sent to the National Human Rights Council or its relevant regional commission. The CNDH can request information, conduct monitoring and issue recommendations, but it does not replace the public prosecutor or award criminal damages.
The Institution of the Ombudsman of the Kingdom may examine maladministration involving public authorities. It is more suitable for administrative abuse, failure to respond or procedural obstruction than for determining criminal guilt.
After available and effective domestic remedies have been exhausted, a victim may consider an individual communication to a United Nations treaty body, particularly the Committee against Torture where its jurisdictional requirements are met. The case must not ordinarily be pending before another international mechanism, and the applicant must explain any failure to exhaust domestic remedies. These proceedings take time, but requests for interim measures may be crucial where removal to a risk of torture is imminent.
Undocumented migrants: rights that do not disappear
Access to courts and police
An undocumented migrant can bring a case in Morocco. Neither the constitutional right of access to justice nor the basic ability to report a crime is reserved to residence-card holders. A victim can file a complaint, testify, seek damages and, under the applicable conditions, become a civil party.
This does not mean there is no immigration risk. Contact with an authority may reveal irregular residence and trigger separate administrative action. A lawyer or association can help manage that risk, particularly where the person has an asylum claim, serious illness, family ties or another statutory protection.
In police custody, the person should ask for a lawyer, an interpreter and contact with their consulate where appropriate. A refugee or asylum seeker who fears the authorities of the country of origin should tell counsel before consular contact is made. Signing a statement that has not been understood is dangerous; interpretation at busy border courts is sometimes informal or incomplete.
Healthcare and education
Emergency medical treatment should not be denied solely because a patient lacks a residence permit. In reality, access varies by hospital, city and the person’s ability to produce an identity document. A medical emergency and a request for a medico-legal certificate are separate matters, so the patient should state clearly that the injuries may be connected to violence.
Children’s access to schooling was facilitated by Ministry of Education measures adopted after the 2013 migration-policy reform. Implementation remains uneven. Families may need help from an association when a school requests documents that are impossible to obtain.
Older references to RAMED should be treated cautiously. Morocco has been replacing RAMED through the compulsory health-insurance reforms and related social-protection programmes. Eligibility and registration requirements must be checked under the current system rather than assumed from pre-reform guidance.
Regularisation and humanitarian factors
Morocco organised exceptional regularisation campaigns in 2014 and 2016–2017. The first campaign resulted in more than 23,000 favourable decisions, and the later campaign produced tens of thousands of additional applications and regularisations. Criteria included family relationships, lengthy residence, employment, serious illness and particular vulnerability.
Those campaigns did not create a permanent automatic right to regularisation. A person should nevertheless build a documentary file: rent receipts, medical records, school certificates, employment evidence, proof of family ties, association attestations and copies of previous applications. A coherent five-year paper trail can change the outcome of a later administrative request.
Claims that Article 18 of Law No. 02-03 creates a general, automatic “humanitarian residence permit” should also be approached carefully. Humanitarian circumstances can influence administrative decisions and protection against removal, but the statute does not provide a simple on-demand card comparable to some European systems.
Finding a lawyer and obtaining legal assistance
Legal aid in Morocco
Legal aid is rooted in Article 121 of the Constitution and Morocco’s legal-aid legislation, historically including Royal Decree-Law No. 514-65 of 1 November 1966, as amended. Law No. 42-10 should not be cited as the general legal-aid statute; it concerns neighbourhood courts.
An application is generally made through the legal-aid office attached to the competent court, with evidence of insufficient resources and documents relating to the case. Eligibility for a foreign national is not accurately reduced to a universal monthly threshold of 750 dirhams. Nationality, reciprocity, treaty obligations, the nature of the proceedings and demonstrated indigence may all matter.
In urgent removal cases, the ordinary legal-aid process may be too slow. The applicant should still request assistance, but simultaneously contact the local bar, its duty service and a migration-rights organisation. For criminal custody, court-appointed counsel follows the rules of the Code of Criminal Procedure and is distinct from ordinary civil legal aid.
Which lawyer should be contacted?
A border-violence case may require two specialities: an administrative-law lawyer to challenge removal and a criminal lawyer to handle the violence complaint. Local knowledge matters. An immigration lawyer in Nador will understand the Melilla context and local court practice, while an immigration lawyer in Oujda may be better placed for measures connected to the eastern border.
For asylum registration and proceedings involving the BRA, counsel in Rabat may be practical. Directories for immigration lawyers in Rabat, Tangier and Casablanca can help locate a member of the territorially competent bar.
Private fees vary widely. A first consultation may cost several hundred dirhams, while urgent litigation can cost several thousand dirhams depending on travel, interpretation and complexity. Fees should be discussed in writing. No honest lawyer can guarantee asylum recognition or the release of a detainee.
Associations as the first legal safety net
GADEM provides legal information and advocacy on foreigners’ rights. Caritas Morocco offers social and referral services through several local programmes. The OMDH and other human-rights organisations may document serious violations or refer victims to counsel. Medical organisations can treat injuries and direct patients toward legal support, although their geographic presence and projects change over time.
For the first meeting, bring every available document: passport, UNHCR document, police paper, removal order, medical certificate, photographs, hospital receipt, proof of residence and telephone numbers of witnesses. Keep originals and provide copies. If the document is in Arabic and the client cannot read Arabic, counsel should explain it before any signature or procedural decision.
What should happen next?
Investigations in Spain into conduct at Ceuta or Melilla should encourage equivalent transparency on the Moroccan side. Border cooperation does not divide responsibility so neatly that each state can point to the other. When Moroccan officers are alleged to have used unlawful force, Moroccan prosecutors and courts have jurisdiction. When Spanish officers exercise control or return people without safeguards, Spanish and European remedies may apply.
The greater structural problem remains Morocco’s missing asylum law. More than a decade after the 2013 policy shift, the delay is increasingly difficult to justify. Administrative practice and UNHCR cooperation cannot permanently replace legislation defining status, deadlines, appeal rights, reception conditions and protection against arbitrary removal. The vacuum benefits uncertainty and, at times, administrative discretion.
For migrants, the final advice is direct: do not wait for a removal bus to look for legal help. Register a protection claim early, preserve documents, identify a lawyer or association and keep emergency contact numbers offline. Rights exist even for undocumented people. Exercising them is difficult, but a dated medical certificate, a copy of a decision and an application filed within 48 hours can determine whether a case is heard at all.
