Death penalty in Moroccan criminal law: a punishment suspended, but not abolished
The courtroom had gone completely silent. A few moments earlier, the prosecution had requested the death penalty. Sitting beside his lawyer, the accused lowered his eyes and placed a trembling hand on the wooden rail. He had known that capital punishment was legally possible, but hearing it demanded aloud changed everything. For the accused and his family, the Moroccan moratorium suddenly meant very little: the words death sentence had entered the case file.
This scene, familiar to criminal lawyers handling the most serious cases before Morocco's criminal chambers, captures the central contradiction of the death penalty in Moroccan criminal law. Morocco has not carried out an execution since 1993. It is therefore commonly described as an abolitionist state in practice. Nevertheless, capital punishment remains in the Criminal Code, military legislation and several provisions concerning terrorism or national security. Moroccan courts continue to pronounce death sentences.
The debate has acquired renewed regional significance as Algeria, Tunisia and Mauritania reconsider the place of capital punishment in their respective legal systems. In Morocco, it also intersects with the constitutional right to life, the reform of criminal procedure, public concern after particularly violent crimes and the country's changing position at the United Nations.
So, is Morocco genuinely abolitionist, or does it merely keep executions on hold? The legally accurate answer lies somewhere between those two positions. For a broader explanation of offences, investigations and criminal trials, readers may also consult this guide to criminal law in Morocco.
Why the issue remains current after more than three decades without executions
A moratorium is not the same thing as abolition. Abolition removes the punishment from legislation, preventing a court from imposing it. A moratorium suspends executions through political and administrative practice while leaving the legal provisions intact.
That distinction has immediate consequences. A defendant can still hear a prosecutor request death. A criminal chamber can still impose it. A person can remain under a final death sentence for years while waiting for a commutation or royal pardon. The execution may be unlikely, but the legal uncertainty and psychological burden are real.
Legal foundations of the death penalty in Morocco
The 1962 Criminal Code and Article 16
The principal text is the Criminal Code approved by Dahir no. 1-59-413 of 28 Joumada II 1382, corresponding to 26 November 1962. Although amended repeatedly, it continues to form the backbone of substantive Moroccan criminal law.
Article 16 of the Moroccan Criminal Code classifies death, life imprisonment and imprisonment for a term of five to thirty years among the principal criminal punishments.
Capital punishment therefore occupies the highest position in the statutory scale. It is followed by life imprisonment, often called réclusion perpétuelle, and then fixed-term criminal imprisonment. References to penalties as both afflictive and infamous also appear in the general structure of the Code, although the practical consequences of older terminology must be read alongside the Constitution and subsequent legislation.
Article 17 of the Criminal Code states that a person sentenced to death is executed by shooting. Other provisions address the place and conditions of execution, including special rules relating to pregnant women. These provisions have not been used since 1993, but they have not disappeared from positive law.
The constitutional tension: the right to life and the royal pardon
Article 20 of the Constitution of 2011: “The right to life is the first right of every human being. The law protects this right.”
Abolitionists consider Article 20 a constitutional basis for removing capital punishment. Supporters of retention reply that the Constitution did not expressly declare the death penalty unconstitutional and that the constituent authority left Parliament free to determine criminal sanctions. No authoritative ruling of the Constitutional Court has yet struck down the statutory death penalty on the sole basis of Article 20.
The Constitution also creates the principal institutional mechanism through which death sentences may be reduced:
Article 58 of the Constitution: “The King exercises the right of pardon.”
A royal pardon may remit or reduce a sentence. In capital cases, it can commute death to life imprisonment or another custodial sentence. It should not be confused with an acquittal or the quashing of a conviction: the finding of guilt remains, while the punishment changes.
No statutory deadline requires the Sovereign to decide a pardon request within a particular number of months or years. In practice, collective pardons are frequently announced around national and religious occasions, including the Throne Day, but a condemned prisoner cannot claim commutation as an automatic right.
Recent reforms have not abolished capital punishment
Claims that a single reform enacted in 2016 or 2022 substantially removed the Moroccan death penalty are misleading. Various draft Criminal Code reforms have proposed reducing the number of capital offences, but the core provisions remain in force. Likewise, Law no. 43-22 on alternative sentences reflects a more rehabilitative penal philosophy, yet it concerns alternatives such as community service, electronic monitoring and day-fines. It does not convert capital offences into ordinary alternative-sanction cases.
In clear terms, abolition can be achieved through an ordinary legislative amendment to the Criminal Code and related special statutes. A constitutional revision is not legally indispensable because the Constitution does not require capital punishment. The principal obstacle is political and legislative, not technical.
Which crimes are punishable by death in Morocco?
The expression crimes punishable by death in Morocco covers more than intentional homicide. Capital provisions are scattered through the Criminal Code and special legislation. Their application also depends on precise constituent elements: intention, premeditation, the result caused, the status of the victim and, in some cases, wartime circumstances.
Premeditated murder, parricide and other aggravated killings
Article 392 of the Criminal Code punishes murder with death when it is preceded, accompanied or followed by another felony, and also addresses murder committed to prepare, facilitate or complete another felony or to assist the perpetrators in escaping or avoiding punishment. Premeditated murder and murder by lying in wait are also punished by death under the Code's homicide provisions.
The terminology requires care. Under Moroccan law, ordinary intentional homicide does not invariably lead to capital punishment. The prosecution must establish the aggravating circumstance specified by the relevant text, such as premeditation or lying in wait. Premeditation means a formed intention to attack a particular person, or a person who may be encountered, before the act. It is not established merely because the attack was brutal.
Article 396 punishes parricide by death. Parricide means the intentional killing of an ascendant, such as a father, mother or other legally recognised ancestor. Article 398 concerns poisoning, while Article 399 provides capital punishment where murder is preceded, accompanied or followed by acts of torture or barbarity.
Other offences may become capital when they cause death. These include certain forms of kidnapping, unlawful detention, arson or destruction, depending on the exact statutory provision and result. The indictment must identify the applicable article; a general reference to the seriousness of the facts is not enough.
Sexual violence: correcting a common misconception
Rape is an extremely serious felony, but it is inaccurate to state that rape automatically carries the death penalty under Moroccan law. The punishment depends on the victim's age, aggravating circumstances, the offender's status and the consequences of the assault. Where sexual violence is combined with a separate capital homicide, the death penalty may be sought for the killing, not simply because the underlying conduct was rape.
The former Article 475, repealed in 2014, did not create a death penalty for rape. It became notorious because its second paragraph could allow a person who abducted or deceived a minor to avoid prosecution by marrying her. Its repeal followed national outrage after the death of Amina Filali. Confusing that provision with capital punishment distorts both the old law and the reform.
Crimes against the internal or external security of the State
Articles in the part of the Criminal Code dealing with State security punish exceptionally serious acts such as treason, intelligence with a foreign power, armed attacks against the constitutional order and certain attempts against the life or person of the King or members of the Royal Family. Not every offence between Articles 163 and 206 is punishable by death; the penalty must be checked article by article.
Some capital provisions are also conditional on the consequence of the act or on wartime circumstances. This is particularly relevant to treason and assistance to an enemy. A defence lawyer must therefore examine jurisdiction, the legal classification and each material and intentional element rather than accepting the prosecution's label.
Terrorism since Law no. 03-03
Law no. 03-03 on combating terrorism, promulgated by Dahir no. 1-03-140 of 28 May 2003, inserted Articles 218-1 and following into the Criminal Code and modified procedural rules. Article 218-1 defines a terrorist offence through a combination of an underlying offence and an intentional connection to an individual or collective project aimed at seriously disturbing public order through intimidation, terror or violence.
Terrorist classification does not automatically make every offence capital. The applicable punishment depends on the underlying act, aggravating provisions and consequences, particularly loss of life. These files are procedurally and factually complex, often involving digital evidence, financial trails, intelligence material and several defendants. Early representation by a lawyer familiar with this field is essential; directories of lawyers handling terrorism cases in Morocco may help families identify appropriate counsel.
Military offences and wartime conduct
The Code of Military Justice contains capital provisions for a limited group of offences, particularly certain acts of treason, desertion to the enemy, surrender or espionage in wartime. Military jurisdiction and procedure have been significantly reformed, notably to restrict the trial of civilians by military courts. Still, the exact version of the military legislation in force on the date of the conduct must be reviewed.
Drug trafficking does not automatically carry the death penalty
A persistent rumour claims that simple drug trafficking is punishable by death in Morocco. It is not. Narcotics offences may result in severe imprisonment, fines, confiscation and related customs penalties, but ordinary trafficking in drugs is not, by itself, a capital offence. A separate killing or another independently capital crime committed in connection with trafficking may, of course, change the legal exposure.
Summary of the principal categories
- Aggravated intentional killings: notably premeditated murder, lying in wait, parricide, poisoning and murder accompanied by torture or barbarity.
- Offences resulting in death: certain forms of abduction, detention, arson, destruction or terrorist violence, where the relevant article expressly provides capital punishment.
- State-security offences: selected acts of treason, armed attacks and attacks against protected constitutional institutions.
- Military offences: narrowly defined wartime crimes under military legislation.
- Not automatically capital: ordinary drug trafficking, rape without a separately capital consequence, and ordinary intentional homicide lacking the statutory aggravating circumstances.
The de facto moratorium: no execution since 1993
The last execution in Morocco
Morocco's last execution took place in 1993Mohamed Tabet, convicted in a case involving numerous acts of sexual violence and other grave crimes. Different secondary publications sometimes reproduce inconsistent dates, which is why the legally safe formulation is that no execution has been carried out since 1993 unless an official archival date is being cited.
The Tabet case remains deeply embedded in Moroccan public memory. It also illustrates a recurring difficulty in the abolition debate: exceptionally shocking facts can produce strong public demands for execution, whereas criminal policy must be designed for all cases, including those affected by mistaken identification, unreliable confessions or inadequate defence.
How many prisoners are under sentence of death?
There is no continuously updated public register allowing citizens to verify the number in real time. Amnesty International reported at least 83 people under sentence of death at the end of 2023 in Morocco and Western Sahara, with six new death sentences recorded during that year. Later totals may differ because of new judgments, deaths in custody, successful appeals and royal commutations.
Consequently, the figure often quoted by Moroccan civil-society organisations—roughly 80 to 100 prisoners—should be understood as an estimate tied to a reporting date, not a permanent official count. The absence of regular, disaggregated publication by offence, sex, court, procedural status and year of conviction makes scrutiny difficult.
Death-sentenced prisoners have historically been held in institutions including the central prison at Kénitra and other facilities administered by the General Delegation for Prison Administration and Reintegration, known by its French abbreviation DGAPR. A sentence imposed in Casablanca, Marrakech or Fez does not necessarily mean that the prisoner remains in that city. Families needing local representation may consult criminal lawyers in Marrakech or criminal lawyers in Fez, depending on where proceedings are taking place.
The psychological reality of death row
The absence of executions does not make the sentence harmless. Some prisoners spend many years under a capital judgment, uncertain whether it will be commuted. That prolonged uncertainty affects sleep, mental health, family relationships and prospects for reintegration. International literature describes this as the “death-row phenomenon,” although its recognition as a separate legal violation depends on the jurisdiction and circumstances.
Conditions are not necessarily identical for every condemned prisoner. Classification, access to activities, family visits and medical care depend on prison rules and individual assessments. Sweeping claims that all capital prisoners are held permanently in solitary confinement should therefore be avoided unless supported by current, facility-specific evidence. Greater transparency from the DGAPR would permit a more reliable public assessment.
Royal pardon as the system's safety valve
Royal commutation has prevented legal death sentences from turning into executions. It is, however, an act of clemency rather than a judicial appeal. The pardon process cannot replace an adversarial review of evidence, procedural violations or legal classification by the courts.
There is no dependable “average waiting time” for a capital commutation. Some cases take years and the overall judicial journey—investigation, first-instance trial, appeal and cassation—can itself last approximately three to seven years in a complex multi-defendant prosecution. Any lawyer promising a pardon by a particular national holiday is making a promise that the law does not permit them to guarantee.
Morocco, international law and abolition
The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
Morocco ratified the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights in 1979. Article 6 protects the right to life and, for states that have not abolished the death penalty, restricts its use to the “most serious crimes” following a final judgment rendered by a competent court. The UN Human Rights Committee interprets that phrase narrowly, essentially limiting it to crimes involving intentional killing.
Morocco has not ratified the Second Optional Protocol to the Covenant, whose purpose is abolition of capital punishment. Ratification would require a much clearer commitment to permanent abolition and would restrict the possibility of later reintroduction, subject to the protocol's narrow wartime reservation mechanism.
Morocco's changing vote at the United Nations
For years Morocco abstained on United Nations General Assembly resolutions calling for a universal moratorium on executions, including successive resolutions beginning with Resolution 62/149 in 2007. That posture attempted to reconcile non-execution at home with reluctance to accept an international political commitment.
A major shift occurred in December 2024, when Morocco voted in favour of the General Assembly's biennial resolution calling for a moratorium on the use of the death penalty. This was Morocco's first supportive vote after a long pattern of abstention. The vote did not itself amend the Moroccan Criminal Code, but it strengthened the political case for aligning domestic legislation with longstanding practice.
Thus, an answer stating simply that Morocco “abstains at the UN” is now outdated. The accurate position is evolutionary: historical abstention, followed by a first vote in favour of the moratorium in 2024.
The CNDH and Moroccan civil society
The National Human Rights Council, or CNDH, has supported abolition and has repeatedly connected the issue to constitutional protection of life and Morocco's international commitments. The Moroccan Coalition Against the Death Penalty brings together associations, lawyers and human-rights advocates seeking statutory abolition, improved prison conditions and publication of reliable statistics.
Professional opinion within the legal community is not entirely uniform. Many lawyers support abolition because irreversible punishment is incompatible with the possibility of judicial error. Others favour retention for terrorism, the murder of children or particularly cruel crimes. What unites most practitioners is the need for stronger procedural safeguards whenever the prosecution seeks the ultimate sentence.
Religion, qisas and the role of the State
Religious argument has a genuine place in Moroccan debate. Classical Islamic jurisprudence recognises qisas, often translated as retaliation in kind, for certain intentional killings. It also gives significance to pardon by the victim's heirs and to compensation through diya. Some scholars argue that the State cannot abolish a sanction rooted in these principles without addressing the rights of victims' families.
Other jurists respond that modern capital offences are imposed by the State under a codified penal system and do not reproduce the classical law of qisas in every respect. They invoke siyasa shar'iyya—public policy guided by the objectives of Islamic law—to defend suspension or abolition where required by the public interest, the prevention of injustice and the risk of irreversible error.
No definitive, universally binding opinion from Morocco's Higher Council of Ulema has settled every aspect of legislative abolition. The issue cannot honestly be reduced to the slogan that Islam either commands or forbids the current Moroccan system.
Appeals and defence rights in capital cases
Assistance by a lawyer must begin early
The Moroccan Code of Criminal Procedure, promulgated by Dahir no. 1-02-255 of 3 October 2002 and subsequently amended, regulates police custody, judicial investigation, trial and remedies. Article 66 contains safeguards applicable during police custody, including notification of rights and regulated communication with counsel, subject to the legal regime and possible postponements applicable to certain offences.
In serious felony cases, waiting until trial to appoint counsel can be disastrous. Statements made during police custody, forensic examinations, telephone extractions, searches, identification procedures and reconstruction reports may determine the entire direction of the prosecution. Defence counsel should test the lawfulness of custody, the integrity of evidence, the presence of coercion and the consistency of medical or technical findings.
Families can seek a criminal lawyer in Casablanca or a criminal lawyer in Rabat as soon as detention is confirmed. They should bring the detention location, police report reference if available, summonses, identity documents and any medical or alibi evidence. A detailed overview is available in this explanation of Moroccan criminal procedure from complaint to judgment.
First-instance trial, appeal and cassation
Felonies are tried by the criminal chamber of the competent court of appeal. The current system provides review before an appellate criminal chamber, followed, where legally available, by a petition to the Court of Cassation in Rabat. Cassation is not a third trial on the facts: the Court principally examines legal errors, jurisdiction, reasoning, procedural nullities and correct application of the law.
Criminal appeal periods are short. Depending on the remedy, decision and manner of notification, the applicable period is commonly measured in ten days, not months. The assertion sometimes made that every cassation appeal benefits from an automatic 30-day period is unsafe under Moroccan criminal procedure. Counsel must verify the current consolidated text and the procedural record immediately after judgment. Never allow a deadline to run on the strength of a general internet summary.
The defence should obtain the operative judgment, record the date of pronouncement or service, file the declaration with the competent registry and preserve proof of filing. Where a death sentence is involved, representation by counsel and rigorous review of the judgment's reasoning are indispensable.
Judicial review and royal pardon are different remedies
- Appeal permits review within the ordinary court structure, including factual and legal issues according to the applicable procedural rules.
- Cassation challenges legal and procedural defects before the Court of Cassation.
- Royal pardon, based on Article 58 of the Constitution, concerns clemency and may reduce or remit punishment; it does not erase the judicial conviction.
- Exceptional remedies may arise in narrowly defined circumstances, for example where new facts support review of a wrongful conviction.
A pardon application should be documented rather than emotional only. It may include final judgments, evidence of conduct in prison, health and family information, rehabilitation efforts and submissions concerning proportionality. No private intermediary can lawfully guarantee the result.
How much does a defence in a capital case cost?
Moroccan lawyers' fees are generally agreed with the client and vary according to experience, the number of defendants, the city, the volume of evidence and the number of hearings. For a complex felony carrying a possible death sentence, private fees may realistically range from 50,000 to 200,000 dirhams, sometimes more where proceedings last several years, involve expert evidence or require appearances in several courts.
The written fee agreement should clarify whether the amount covers the investigation stage, trial, appeal, cassation, travel, experts and pardon submissions. A low initial quotation may cover only one procedural stage.
People without sufficient means may apply for legal aid. Yet the gap between legal principle and courtroom reality must be stated frankly. Court-appointed lawyers often work conscientiously, but some carry heavy caseloads, receive limited compensation and obtain the file late. Capital defence requires time for prison visits, witness investigation, expert review and written pleadings—resources that the legal-aid system does not always provide adequately. This guide to legal aid in Morocco explains the practical application process.
Contacting the CNDH and international mechanisms
A prisoner or family may submit a complaint to the CNDH concerning alleged torture, detention conditions or other human-rights violations. The complaint should identify the prisoner, institution, dates, prior steps and supporting documents. The CNDH is not an appellate court and cannot quash a conviction, but it can investigate within its mandate, issue recommendations and refer matters to competent authorities.
International mechanisms may include communications to United Nations special procedures or, where admissibility requirements are satisfied, treaty bodies. These procedures are specialised and do not automatically suspend domestic enforcement. Domestic remedies ordinarily need to be exhausted, and submissions must be factually precise.
Death penalty, life imprisonment and alternative sentences
Life imprisonment is the penalty immediately below death in Article 16. In practice, it is the principal destination of royal commutations. But “life” should not be casually translated as a guaranteed release after a fixed number of years.
Conditional release may become legally examinable after the minimum period specified by the Code of Criminal Procedure, commonly twenty years for a person serving life imprisonment, subject to stricter rules in certain cases. Eligibility is not entitlement. The authorities assess conduct, rehabilitation, public safety and other statutory considerations. A court may also impose a security period affecting eligibility under the relevant provisions.
Law no. 43-22 on alternative sentences represents a significant shift for less serious custodial penalties. It does not provide community service or electronic monitoring as a substitute for death or life imprisonment in capital cases. Realistic alternatives to capital punishment in Morocco therefore centre on life imprisonment, long fixed terms, structured sentence review and stronger rehabilitation mechanisms.
Regional comparison: Tunisia, Algeria and Mauritania
Tunisia has maintained a de facto moratorium since 1991 while retaining death sentences in law. Its post-revolution constitutional debate has not produced full legislative abolition. Algeria also retains capital punishment and has not executed anyone since 1993, but legislative proposals and political reactions to grave crimes periodically revive calls to broaden or use it.
Mauritania retains the death penalty and its legislation is more explicitly influenced by Islamic criminal-law concepts, although long periods without confirmed executions have also occurred. These neighbours show that a moratorium can last decades without becoming legally irreversible.
Morocco nevertheless has features supporting further movement: Article 20 of the Constitution, the CNDH's abolitionist position, more than thirty years without execution and the 2024 UN vote. Portugal is sometimes cited in Moroccan discussions as an example of a country that abolished capital punishment early and later built a democratic criminal justice system without it. Comparisons must account for different histories, but they rebut the notion that public security necessarily requires executions.
What reform is likely to come next?
The National Action Plan on Democracy and Human Rights placed penal reform and human-rights compliance on the public agenda. Draft Criminal Code debates have repeatedly considered reducing the number of capital offences, but legislative progress has been uneven. A partial reduction would be politically easier than immediate total abolition, yet it would preserve the basic contradiction.
Several routes remain possible: remove capital punishment from ordinary crimes first; restrict it to wartime military offences; replace all death sentences with life imprisonment subject to structured review; or enact complete abolition and ratify the Second Optional Protocol to the ICCPR. Parliament could implement any of these approaches through legislation without waiting for constitutional amendment.
In my professional view, maintaining a punishment that the State has refused to execute for more than three decades creates unnecessary legal insecurity. It prolongs suffering for prisoners and families while relying on discretionary pardon to correct what legislation declines to resolve. One can recognise victims' pain, demand severe punishment and still conclude that an irreversible penalty has no safe place in a justice system administered by human beings.
Conclusion: Morocco stands between moratorium and abolition
Morocco is not abolitionist in law. The Moroccan Criminal Code still provides capital punishment for aggravated killings and selected crimes involving terrorism, State security and military conduct. Courts continue to impose death sentences. At the same time, the absence of executions since 1993, repeated commutations, Article 20 of the Constitution and Morocco's supportive UN vote in 2024 all point towards abolition.
The next decisive step must come from Parliament: reduce or repeal the capital provisions, define the consequences for existing sentences and reinforce fair-trial guarantees. Until then, the death penalty remains a legal sword suspended over defendants, even if the executive has chosen not to let it fall.
If you or a relative is involved in a serious criminal case, act from the first hours of custody. Preserve documents, avoid discussing facts publicly and obtain counsel who regularly handles felony investigations and criminal appeals. You can find a lawyer in Morocco or review the broader Moroccan criminal-law guide. In a capital case, deadlines are unforgiving and early procedural decisions may shape every stage that follows.
